Giles G-200 Cowling

I’m very happy to report that I’m starting a project on a Giles G-200 cowling.  My friend Aaron Burhoe of Burhoe Machine Works up in Sonora, California is building a Giles G-200.  For those unfamiliar with the Giles, it’s a single seat unlimited acrobat, made primarily of carbon fiber.  He’s been unhappy with the stock cowl for some time – it’s too blunt, boxy, and really not all that attractive.  Here’s a pic he sent me:

Surely, I said, we can do better than that.  I’m tentatively scheduled to fly up there next week, once he has the engine hung on the mount.  I’ll bring the FARO arm to digitize the firewall, spinner and engine.  In the meantime, let’s get started on the surface model.  Wait, what?  You might be asking “how do you start a surface model when you haven’t even gotten the plane digitized?”  Well, this is truly one of the places where T-Splines just blows my mind.  Traditional NURBS modeling packages generate surfaces by taking input curves and surfaces and using those as input for a new surface.  So if I was using standard Rhino, I would have to wait until after I digitized the plane to start.  T-Splines on the other hand is topology based – meaning the way I define the entire surface and how the faces of that surface relate to each other is what allows me to generate the final surface.  T-Splines surfaces are unified, so I can edit them at any time without affecting other parts of the model.  So this means I can figure out HOW I want to model the spinner ring and inlets, without having to concern myself with the part of the cowl that mates to the fuselage.  Once I get on site and have the relevant sections digitized, I can simply match my existing T-Spline surface to that geometry, and then style and tweak the model.

The biggest part of the learning curve for me in switching to T-Splines was to get to the point where I could visualize the topology that would work for the particular project I was working on BEFORE I started the model.  What it comes down to is figuring out where your t points and star points should be.  The best short explanation of them, that I can offer, can be found here on the T-Splines forum.  So while I was driving around town the other day, I started thinking about what my topology will look like for this cowling.  At the most basic level, a cowling resembles a box with one side removed.  Okay, so let’s start with that – T-Splines can generate “primitives” which can be used a nice a starting point for models.  So I generated a box primitive, deleted one side and then used tsLayout to look at the star point locations:

No surprise to those of us who use T-Splines, you’ve got four star points, one on each corner.  The next step is to subdivide the faces, we obviously want more control than this.  So I next go something like this:

This should be enough topology to make a very sleek and sexy cowl – really!  The next thing to figure out is what the holes for the spinner ring and inlets should look like.  I deleted the center four faces, extruded it inwards, and then deleted the two more faces on each side and extruded that edge loop down.  I also enabled symmetry.  So the topology now looks like this:

You can see the four original star points around the edge.  The eight additional points are for the inlets and spinner ring.  Here’s what this looks like in smooth mode:

Well that doesn’t look attractive, but believe it or not, all it takes from here is some point editing.  I used tsMatch to force the spinner ring into a circle, and put a crease between the spinner ring and the area inside of it.  Other than that, all it took was 45 minutes of point editing to get here:

Well that certainly looks promising!  I know that I can use this as a starting point for my design.  Note the location of the t-points:

They are all in areas of relatively low curvature, which helps greatly in keeping the model smooth.  If I need to add more points to match the firewall, I can do that easily – in fact I can use the tsMatch command and it will insert extra points automatically if I need it to.   Basically, the hard part of this job is done, and I haven’t even shown up yet to do the work!

Comments
7 Responses to “Giles G-200 Cowling”
  1. Greg says:

    nicely done, keep it up!

  2. Michael says:

    Sky, this is beautiful work.

    Not quite following this part:

    “I used tsMatch to force the spinner ring into a circle, and put a crease between the spinner ring and the area inside of it.”

    In the manual, it says tsMatch is applied to two surfaces, one NURBS and the other tSplines. So I am guessing you may done this somewhat as follows:

    1) positioned a NURBs cylinder in place of (and along the axis of) the spinner?
    2) tsMatched the edge of the cylinder to the edge of the spinner cutout in the cowl?

    But there must be more to your method, since there is a circular flat, or washer shape, under the spinner.

    I know this must be utterly basic stuff, but I would appreciate it if you could elaborate on the steps you took to create the “washer.”

    Many thanks, Michael

  3. Michael –

    tsMatch works just as well with a curve for the matching object. Of course there is no surface tangency information in a curve, but for a spinner ring on a cowl like that that doesn’t matter. If, say, I was doing some Formula 1 aircraft cowl that had a nice long prop extension on the shaft, I would probably use tsMatch and match the cowl surface to the back of the spinner surface (the spinner surface being NURBS…..actually, now that I think about it, you can probably use tsMatch and use a T-Spline surface as the matching object). Does that make sense?

    -Sky

  4. Michael says:

    Thank you, Sky.

    Maybe the whole spinner ring, or washer-like surface, is NURBs?

    Not quite seeing why it would be useful here to match a tSplines surface instead of, maybe, using tsMerge or welding.

    I think of tSplines surfaces as being made out of “bubble blow,” the soapy stuff we used as kids to blow bubbles out of a wire ring.

    What appeals to me about tsMatch is its apparent ability to impose (force) a machined, fixed surface onto a fluid changeable tSplines surface. I did a model airplane cowl in tSplines, just using a hexagon to make a circle. Eventually, as I continued to work with it, it wandered out of round. In the end I converted to Rhino and cleaned it up with Trim.

    I am currently trying to model a transmission case. The original was cast and then machined. The tsMatch seems like the perfect tool for handling the machined surfaces. Can’t use good old Trim.

    In the early versions of tsplines, I could never get tsMatch to actually work, so I sort of set it aside. It appears that in the current versions, it works great.

    Michael

  5. Michael –

    The whole point of using tsMatch is to make the spinner ring round – or very nearly as close to it as it can be. Since the whole thing is a degree 3 surface, all the surrounding geometry acts to pull the spinner ring out of true. tsMatch is simply the quickest and easiest way to get it back to circular.

    -Sky

  6. Michael says:

    Thanks for this help. I am encouraged to get back into tSplines and try this technique. The pattern is, I try tsplines for a while, hit the wall — give it up for a few months — and then go back and try it again.

    Couple of links you might enjoy. The model airplane cowl I did a year and half ago is here:

    http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showpost.php?p=14936929&postcount=12

    This one, I made first in Rhino, then converted it to tSplines to edit, and then converted it back.

    The transmission project, which has a very similar set of problems, is here.

    http://www.jalopyjournal.com/forum/showpost.php?s=638b51847e623287dfec6cef171cbe0a&p=6941872&postcount=82

    In both case you have a very precisely machined metal surface surrounded by, in essence, melted cheese.

    All best, Michael

  7. Ramon says:

    Hi Sky,

    I’ve just started to use TSplines and I’m currently trying to work through your cowling tutorial. Can I ask the method you used to make the raised section of the spinner ring? I can seem to get it to work. I have removed the four faces etc but then get stuck. Any help would be appreciated.

    Cheers

    Ramon

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: